Progress towards a biotypic biomarker profile for amyotrophic lateral sclerosis–frontotemporal spectrum disorders

Abstract

Determining the optimal timing of disease-modifying therapies for neurodegenerative disorders will necessitate identification of when the underlying pathobiological process becomes active, well in advance of the point at which clinical manifestions appear. Phenoconversion, the emergence of clinically manifest syndomes, may be preceded by years to decades of silent pathobiological activity that can only be mapped by an array of biomarkers. ALS and FTD, traditionally identified as distinct clinical syndromes, are increasingly recognized to exist along a spectrum of clinical syndromes with shared genetic risk and shared underlying pathology. This clinicopathological spectrum is underpinned by cytoplasmic aggregation of TAR DNA-binding protein 43 (TDP-43) as the common neuropathological hallmark. In contrast, the majority of neuropathologically-defined frontotemporal lobar degeneration (FTLD) is associated with alterations in either TDP-43 metabolism (FTLD-TDP) or of the microtubule associated protein tau (FTLD-tau), with a smaller percentage associated with either autosomal dominant genetic mutations or impairments in the ubiquitin proteasome system. As the field of neurodegenerative disorders increasingly shifts towards the frameworks of a pathobiological definition of disease, there is a growing imperative to develop biomarkers that reflect the varied pathobiologies that underly these disorders, and to determine the sensitivity of such biomarkers to detect the presence of these pathobiologies before phenoconversion. To that end, an international workshop was convened in London, Canada in 2025 to review the evidence for existing or evolving biomarkers suitable for (1) the detection of either ALS or FTD pathobiology prior to phenoconversion and/or (2) predict phenoconversion in at risk individuals. Such biomarkers might be conceptualized as “biotypic biomarkers”, capturing their ability to describe an underlying pathophysiology whilst being agnostic to the emergent clinical manifestations. Whereas no single biotypic marker is yet able to predict the emergence of ALS, FTD or their intersection, a multimodal approach to developing a biotypic biomarker profile holds promise for the detection of relevant pathobiological processes. The strength of such an approach would be augmented by also addressing issues of resiliency/susceptibility both in terms of genetic risk susceptibility profiles and developing sensitive biomarkers of genomic and cellular aging. By including such nontraditional markers of disease, a more robust picture of not only the degenerative process but also of those factors that might potentially mitigate or drive a heightened probability of disease can be derived.